Technical Resource Center

Comparison

WATER RING V/P SYSTEM

WATER SEALED V/P SYSTEM DRY TYPE VACUUM PUMP SYSTEM
Pressure varies with cooling water temperature (in summer). Cooling water temperature has no effect on vacuum.
Noise & abrasion due to cavitation.
(By using an air ejector, cavitation is prevented and vacuum efficiency will be improved.)
No vacuum variation during summertime temperatures.
Power & cooling water consumption is higher than capacity. Wastewater contamination problem. Utility cost is 1/2–1/10 that of a water-sealed vacuum pump.
Capacity limited to low vacuum (200–50 Torr). Suitable for high vacuum (100–10⁻² Torr).
Power & investment costs will be much higher to create large capacity. Compared with current systems, greater cost savings are achieved at larger capacities.

OIL ROTARY V/P SYSTEM

OIL ROTARY V/P SYSTEM DRY SCREW VACUUM PUMP
Initial vacuum is good, but vacuum varies during operation. Dry-type vacuum pump provides constant vacuum.
Condensed vapor and moisture emulsify with vacuum oil and cause process instability. Suitable for compressed vapor or moisture.
Vane or piston abrasion is high. Maintenance is difficult. No oil change is needed.
(However, bearing oil should be changed every 3–6 months.)
Frequent vacuum oil changes are required. No contact between the rotor and casing. No water is required.
Limited capacity. Suitable only for small sizes. Suitable for any capacity (5–300 m³/min), from low to high capacity.
Power consumption is too high compared with capacity. Saves 1/2–1/5 of power consumption compared with an oil rotary vacuum pump of the same size.

STEAM BOOSTER SYSTEM

STEAM BOOSTER SYSTEM DRY SCREW VACUUM PUMP
Excessive utility costs (steam and cooling water). Utility costs are 1/10–1/15 of those of a steam booster.
Wastewater and pollution problems caused by the use of a barometric condenser. Eliminates wastewater problems.
Cooling-water temperature rises during summer (in the barometric condenser), resulting in unstable product quality. Maintains a constant vacuum and stabilizes the process despite variations in summer water temperatures.
Requires a large installation space relative to its capacity. Compact size relative to capacity saves installation space.
High maintenance costs due to nozzle abrasion over long-term use. Easy maintenance.
Simple operation through system automation.